What Is Ailing Manchester United?
Manchester United’s worst start in 40 years explained: managerial churn, recruitment gaps, Lisandro Martínez’s criticism of the board and £1.1bn of debt.

Update, 20 November 2026: Manchester United dismissed Michael Carrick as head coach on 12 November 2026, after this article was first published.
Manchester United’s problems are now both sporting and structural. The club has made its worst start to a Premier League season in 40 years and has gone five matches without a win, including a 2–0 Champions League defeat by Atlético Madrid.
Pressure on the manager
The pressure is also falling on manager Michael Carrick, who became the latest United coach to face serious scrutiny after a difficult run of results. The club has already dismissed Erik ten Hag and Ruben Amorim in the past two seasons, raising concerns about constant managerial change and the absence of a stable long-term footballing plan.
Recruitment gaps
Recruitment has become a central issue. United spent approximately £140–155 million during the summer on midfielders including Carlos Baleba, Andrey Santos and Youri Tielemans. However, the club did not add a striker to support Benjamin Šeško or bring in clear competition at left-back, despite weaknesses in both positions. Injuries to Šeško and Luke Shaw have made those omissions appear even more damaging.
Ad spaceYour brand here, next to the storyAdvertise →Frustration inside the squad
Lisandro Martínez’s public criticism of the board has exposed the frustration inside the squad. Following the Atlético defeat, he questioned the club’s ambition and recruitment strategy, placing renewed attention on football director Jason Wilcox and the wider leadership structure. Although Martínez later apologised, the incident revealed how quickly sporting disappointment can become an internal crisis.
Instability at the top
United’s difficulties are compounded by uncertainty at executive level. Dan Ashworth was dismissed only months after becoming sporting director, while senior decision-makers remain under pressure over recruitment and football strategy. That instability makes it difficult to build a squad designed for one consistent style of play.
Debt and the stadium question
Finance is another concern. United’s reported overall debt stands at approximately £1.1 billion, while supporters have questioned whether major spending plans, including a proposed new stadium costing more than £2 billion, should take priority over strengthening the first-team squad.
What United need now
The solution is unlikely to be another isolated transfer or another hurried managerial dismissal. United need clarity over ownership and leadership, a coherent recruitment model, better injury management and patience with a clearly defined tactical system. The club still possesses global reach, commercial strength and access to elite talent, but those advantages must finally be converted into sporting stability.
Check Premier League scores and tables in the SportZ.fit Live Match Centre.